Easy Homemade Marinara Sauce Recipe (2024)

Published: Dec 19, 2022 by Sally Cameron · This post may contain affiliate links · Leave a Comment

With simple ingredients that are pantry staples, make this easy homemade marinara sauce recipe in about 30 minutes. Use it for dinner over pasta or chicken, then freeze leftover sauce for an even faster dinner on busy weeknights. Save money and make your own marinara. It's the best!

A friend recently commented that the famous Italian restaurant jarred marinara sauce her kids liked was so expensive. I served her some of my homemade marinara and she loved it. Plus, it can be made for less than half of the cost of the stuff she's been buying. Store bought sauces are fine in a pinch, but skip the jars and make your own marinara sauce.

Why You'll Like This Recipe

• It's simple using basic pantry ingredients like canned tomatoes.
• Tasty and easy no matter what you call it (spaghetti sauce, pasta sauce, simple tomato sauce, or marinara). A staple in the kitchen.
• Make it ahead and freeze it in batches for fast meals.

Recipe Ingredients

Here are the ingredients for my go-to homemade marinara sauce. See recipe card for all ingredients and quantities.

• Cooking fat: use extra virgin olive oil to saute the onion and garlic in for great flavor and healthy fat.
• Onion: onion gives flavor depth and a base for the sauce. A foundational ingredient for soups, stews, sauces and many recipes.
• Garlic: fresh garlic is best and a head keeps in a cool pantry for some time. You can use the peeled refrigerated cloves but be sure they are fresh.
• Basil: this recipe uses dried herbs and fresh. Use plain dried basil or an Italian seasoning blend. I use fresh in addition to dried herbs for more flavor at the end. Fresh basil (all fresh herbs) should be added at the end of cooking.
• Other herbs and spices: ground anise seed or ground fennel seed make a terrific and unexpected flavor addition to this marinara sauce recipe. What's the difference? Fennel seed is milder and less sweet while anise seed has a little more potent and sweeter flavor of licorice. Use one or both. They are two different plants. Optional but delicious!
• Tomatoes: use both canned crushed tomatoes and plain canned tomato sauce. Some chef's swear by San Marzano tomatoes as a top choice for flavorful marinara sauce but there are other great options. See more on tomatoes below.
• Red wine:while adding wine is optional, it's a great flavor and aroma enhancer to the sauce. For a small quantity, I cook with the inexpensive airline-sized bottles.

Chef's Tip on tomatoes: Real San Marzano tomatoes are identified by the "certified D.O.P" label on every can. They cost a little more than regular tomatoes but many believe they are worth it. Unfortunately, according to this culinary expert there are counterfeit San Marzano tomatoes in stores (I know, crazy to think) so don't be fooled by labeling (or a higher price). Here are the California-grown tomatoes I usually buy, named one of the best canned tomatoes in 2022.

Substitutions and Variations

Here's ways to change up homemade marinara:

• Make it a spicy sauce: add extra red pepper flakes (pizza pepper)
• Make it a smooth sauce: puree until smooth in a blender, food processor or with an immersion blender
• Make it a meat sauce: add a couple of links of pre-cooked sausage ground fine in a food processor or chopped fine with a chef's knife, or use browned ground beef. Cooked ground bison works well too.
• Alcohol-free: leave out the wine.
• Vary the herbs: try dried oregano instead of the dried basil or dried Italian blend, then add a handful of the fresh chopped herbs at the end.

For Whole Tomatoes

If you only have whole tomatoes, do this. Strain the liquid from the can and reserve in a bowl. Over the sink or a bowl (it's messy), split the tomatoes with your fingers and remove any seeds, then briefly puree with liquid in a blender, food processor, or chop by hand.

Don't puree smooth. Leave some texture. This works in place of crushed tomatoes.

For Tomato Sauce

If you're out of plain tomato sauce but have tomato paste, convert the paste to sauce. Use half tomato paste and half water and stir until smooth. If your sauce gets too thick, thin with a little water.

Another option is to use all crushed tomatoes. The sauce will be chunkier but you can puree it if desired for a smoother marinara sauce.

Recipe Instructions

This homemade marinara sauce recipe is simple in both ingredients and instruction. First, cook onion in the oil until softened and fragrant, then add the garlic and cook briefly. Use a heavy pot like a Dutch oven as they conduct heat evenly and cook over lower temperatures efficiently.

Lastly, taste the sauce. It has too much acidity for you, add a little sugar or neutral flavored sweetener like monk fruit. It's ready to serve or cool and freeze.

Chef's tip on cooking with wine: I use the mini bottles of wine to cook with and save the full-sized bottles for dinner. They are great to keep in the pantry for adding a little to this marinara recipe or for deglazing a pan for a sauce, and they are inexpensive. The cooking rule is use one you would drink, not "cooking wines". Don't add it at the end. It needs to simmer with the sauce.

Serving Suggestions

• Over a big bowl of pasta topped with fresh herbs and parmesan cheese
• For making Chicken Parmesan
• Use it as a dipping sauce
• As a pizza sauce
• Make spicy stovetop shrimp, Italian style
• Simmer Italian meatballs in it

Storage

The yield for this recipe is about 5 cups of sauce. Homemade tomato marinara keeps in the refrigerator 5 days or freeze for a few months in an airtight container.

More Tomato Sauce Recipes

Love tomato marinara? Us too. And here are a few more delicious ideas.

⭐️Did You Make This?

If you make this recipe, please comment and let me know, and if you loved it, please give it a 5 star rating! They really help other readers and I love hearing from you.

📖 Recipe